Guests · · 7 min read

    Why allergic guests don't come back: the fear of the menu

    By Shideh Heravi, Founder

    A guest with a peanut allergy does not sit down at the table to enjoy themselves. They sit down to check. They read the menu twice, they ask the server, they ask again when the food arrives, and they still eat with a trace of doubt. If it goes well, they come back. If it goes wrong just once, or if even asking felt awkward, they never come back, and they tell others. This article describes that evening from the guest's point of view, with the figures that exist, and ends with what the restaurant can do.

    • 62% of people with food allergies report a mental health burden from their allergy, mostly anxiety (USA)1
    • 27 to 43% have already had a reaction linked to a foodservice establishment (Canada)2
    • Almost half of fatal reactions are caused by food from restaurants and foodservice (USA)3

    Fear has a seat at the table

    The largest study on this comes from the USA, from the patient registry of the organisation Food Allergy Research & Education. 1,680 patients and family members were surveyed. Two thirds reported a mental health burden from the allergy: fear of the next reaction, anxiety in everyday life with the allergy, worries about avoiding foods. After a reaction, 54 percent reported anxiety and 32 percent panic.1

    There is no survey of this size for Germany and Austria; food allergies and intolerances: guests in numbers works out how many guests are affected. But there is no reason to assume that someone with an allergy in Dornbirn or Berlin feels any different from someone in Chicago. The allergy is the same, the risk is the same, and the menu is often less forthcoming.

    What actually triggers the fear is not eating at home. There, the person knows every ingredient. It is food that someone else has cooked.

    Why the restaurant is the most dangerous place

    A Canadian study asked 1,000 people with food allergies and 500 without how they behave when eating out. Depending on the sample, 27 to 43 percent of those with allergies had already had an allergic reaction linked to a foodservice establishment.2 That is one in three.

    A work group of American allergists analysed deaths from food allergies over 13 years: almost half were caused by food from restaurants or other foodservice establishments.3 Not because chefs are careless, but because things happen in a kitchen that the guest cannot see:

    • Hidden ingredients. The peanut in the sauce, the celery in the stock, the egg in the breadcrumb coating. What is not on the menu is often not in the server's head either.
    • Cross-contact. The same chopping board, the same fryer, the same spoon. For someone with an allergy, that is enough.
    • The hand-over. The guest tells the server, the server tells the kitchen, the kitchen has three orders at once. Somewhere along the way the information gets lost.
    • Staff knowledge. In a survey of 295 people working in German hospitality, only 40 percent answered all the knowledge questions on food allergies correctly, and only 35 percent could name three foods that trigger allergies.4

    The guest knows this list. They have lived it. And that is why they have developed their own rule.

    The guest's rule: ask once, then decide

    Anyone who lives with an allergy has a finely tuned ear for the answer to the question "Is there milk in this?". There are three answers, and each leads to a different decision:

    1. "I'll just ask in the kitchen." The guest waits. The answer comes, perhaps. It sounds unsure. They order the salad with nothing on it and do not come back.
    2. "No, there's nothing in it." Too quick, too confident. The guest knows that butter is milk and that the server may not know that. They order cautiously and stay on edge.
    3. "Have a look, it's listed for every dish." The server points to the menu or to the QR code. The guest reads for themselves, filters for themselves, decides for themselves. They order what they want, not what is left over.

    Only the third answer turns checking back into a meal. And only the third brings the guest back, with their family, their colleagues, their birthday.

    What the restaurant gets out of it

    A guest with an allergy is a loyal guest once they have come to trust you. They do not like to switch, because every new place is a new risk. They recommend you, because everyone around them knows how hard it is to find a safe restaurant. And they bring people with them, because hardly anyone eats out alone.

    The reverse is also true: a guest who felt like a nuisance on their first visit does not come back. They do not complain. They simply stay away.

    Allergen labelling is mandatory in Austria and Germany.5 The rules in detail are set out in FIC software for allergen labelling in contract catering. But the obligation is met as soon as a sheet of paper is pinned up somewhere. Hospitality begins where the guest does not have to ask.

    What a menu can do

    • Allergens for every dish, not just a note at the end. The guest reads dish by dish; a reference to a notice on the wall interrupts them every time.
    • Complete. The side dish too, the sauce too, the bread too. One dish without information makes all the others less credible.
    • Filterable. On a digital menu, the guest taps "no peanuts" and sees only what they can eat. That is answer number three, without anyone having to ask.
    • Up to date. If an ingredient changes, the menu has to change with it. A guest who once catches an out-of-date entry will not forgive it.
    • Checked. It is the kitchen that decides, not the software. Information that nobody has confirmed is a promise the restaurant cannot keep.

    HealthBlokk reads the menu from a photo or PDF, suggests the 14 allergens listed in Annex II of the EU Food Information to Consumers Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, known in German as LMIV) for each ingredient, and the kitchen approves every entry. Guests see the allergens for every dish via a QR code and filter out what they avoid. Their selection stays on their phone and is not stored anywhere, because an allergy is health data.

    Upload your menu, see the allergens per ingredient. No account, no credit card, in about a minute. Try your menu now

    Frequently asked questions

    How many people with allergies have had a reaction in a restaurant?

    In a Canadian survey of 1,000 people with food allergies, 27 to 43 percent, depending on the sample, had already had a reaction linked to a foodservice establishment. There is no comparable survey for the German-speaking countries.

    Why don't guests always mention their allergy?

    Because asking is awkward and the answer is often uncertain. Many people with allergies would rather order what seems safe to them than send the server back to the kitchen three times. A menu that lists the allergens for every dish removes this hurdle.

    What helps a guest with an allergy the most?

    The allergens for every dish, complete and up to date, and the option to filter for themselves. Then they do not have to ask, do not have to wait and do not have to trust someone they do not know.

    Is allergen labelling on the menu mandatory?

    Yes, throughout the EU since December 2014. In Austria, the Austrian Allergen Information Regulation (Allergeninformationsverordnung) governs how this is done, and the usual approach is the letter code A to R; in Germany, it is the German Food Information Implementing Regulation (LMIDV). Even where information is given verbally, the restaurant needs written documentation for each dish.

    Sources

    1. The mental health burden of food allergies: Insights from the FARE Patient Registry, World Allergy Organization Journal 2024, 1,680 respondents, USA ↩ ↩2

    2. Food Allergy and Foodservice: A Comparative Study of Allergic and Non-Allergic Consumers, Nutrients 2025, Canada ↩ ↩2

    3. Food Allergy in Restaurants Work Group Report, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology: In Practice 2020 ↩ ↩2

    4. Doctoral thesis on knowledge of food allergies in German hospitality, Institute for Occupational, Social and Environmental Medicine, German National Library (in German) ↩

    5. WKO (Austrian Economic Chamber): Allergenkennzeichnung bei offen angebotenen Lebensmitteln in der Gastronomie, allergen labelling for loose foods in hospitality (in German) ↩

    Upload your menu, see the allergens.

    No account, no credit card. In about a minute every dish is in front of you with its allergens.

    Try your menu

    More articles