Compliance · · 13 min read

    Allergen labelling in restaurants: what Austria and Germany require of your menu

    By Shideh Heravi, Founder

    A guest asks whether there is celery in the soup. The server goes to ask the kitchen. The cook says not in the soup itself, but the stock comes out of a tub, and what is in it is written on the label in the storeroom. This is exactly where allergen labelling begins: not with the question of whether a business is honest, but whether it has the answer before the guest asks. This article explains what has applied in Austria and Germany since December 2014, which 14 allergens are meant and where they hide, the three ways of informing guests, what food inspectors check, and how a business with a single menu can set up its labelling in one afternoon.

    • 14 allergens under Annex II of the LMIV, which must be known for every dish and every drink1
    • 13 December 2014: since this date the obligation has applied to unpackaged food throughout the EU1
    • 40 % of the dishes tested from contract catering in Baden-Württemberg were incorrectly or incompletely labelled2

    Who the obligation applies to

    The EU Food Information to Consumers Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, known in German as LMIV) has applied in all member states since 13 December 2014.1 For prepacked food it requires a whole range of particulars, from the list of ingredients to the nutrition table. For unpackaged food, meaning everything served to guests in a restaurant, café, inn, snack bar, bakery, canteen, by a caterer or from a food truck, Article 44 requires only one single piece of information: which of the 14 substances listed in Annex II that can cause allergies or intolerances are present.1 Nutrition information remains voluntary for loose goods.

    The obligation does not depend on the size of the business or its legal form. It applies to the hotel breakfast buffet just as much as to the sausage roll at the petrol station, and it applies to drinks: under EU law, food expressly includes drinks.3 Wine by the glass (sulphites) and draught beer (barley, a cereal containing gluten) therefore belong on the list just as much as the schnitzel.

    How the information has to reach the guest is left to the member states by Article 44(2).1 In Austria this is governed by the Austrian Allergen Information Regulation (Allergeninformationsverordnung) (BGBl. II No 175/2014),4 in Germany by the German Food Information Implementing Regulation (LMIDV), in § 4.5 The basic rule is the same in both countries: the guest must be able to get the information before ordering, without having to fight for it.

    The 14 allergens, and where they hide in the kitchen

    Annex II of the LMIV lists 14 substances and groups of substances. For two of them the general term is not enough: for cereals containing gluten the type of cereal must be named, and for tree nuts the type of nut.1 In Austria, the letter code from the guideline of the Austrian Food Codex (Österreichisches Lebensmittelbuch) has become the standard on menus; the letters I, J, K and Q are not used.6

    Code (AT)AllergenWhere it typically hides
    ACereals containing gluten: wheat, rye, barley, oats, spelt, kamutBreadcrumb coating, roux, soy sauce, beer, bulgur, couscous, seitan, soup garnishes
    BCrustaceansShrimp paste in curry pastes, prawn crackers, fish soup, paella
    CEggsPasta, spätzle, mayonnaise, breadcrumb coating, meringue, glaze on pastries, clarified soups
    DFishWorcestershire sauce, Caesar dressing, fish sauce, fish stock, anchovies in tapenade
    EPeanutsSatay sauce, Asian curries, cereal bars, peanut oil for deep frying
    FSoybeansTofu, soy sauce, miso, edamame, soy lecithin in chocolate, meat substitutes
    GMilk (including lactose)Butter, cream, cheese, whey in baked goods, lactose in sausages, mashed potatoes, ready-made sauces
    HTree nuts: almond, hazelnut, walnut, cashew, pecan, Brazil nut, pistachio, macadamiaPesto, marzipan, nougat, nut bread, chocolates, nut oil in dressings
    LCeleryLiquid seasoning, vegetable stock, stock bases, spice mixes, celery salt, Waldorf salad
    MMustardMayonnaise, dressings, marinades, pickled gherkins, bratwurst, curry sauce
    NSesameBurger buns, tahini, hummus, falafel, sesame oil, Asian salads
    OSulphur dioxide and sulphites above 10 mg/kg or 10 mg/lWine, dried fruit, wine vinegar, horseradish from a jar, peeled potatoes from a bag, prawns
    PLupinLupin flour in baked goods, gluten-free products and vegan spreads
    RMolluscsOyster sauce, mussels, squid, calamari, snails

    The 14 allergens under Annex II of the LMIV with the Austrian letter code16

    Annex II also lists exemptions, such as wheat-based glucose syrup, fish gelatine used as a carrier for vitamins, or fully refined soybean oil.1 They are rarely relevant in the kitchen; if in doubt, it is better to label.

    Allergens are in ingredients, not in dishes

    The goulash has no allergens; its ingredients do: the flour for thickening (A), the liquid seasoning (L), the red wine (O), the cream to finish it (G). Labelling a menu therefore means breaking every dish down into its ingredients, and the ingredients into their components, all the way to the label on the tub.

    Three ways to inform guests

    The LMIDV names three forms: written, electronic and verbal.5 The Austrian regulation recognises written and verbal, with an electronic display counting as written information.47 In practice these are three levels of effort, and the verbal one is the most expensive, even though it looks the simplest.

    1. In writing on the menu. Each dish is followed by letters, numbers or footnote marks, and a key on the same menu explains them. In Austria, the guideline provides for a key headed "Allergeninformation gemäß Codex-Empfehlung" (allergen information according to the Codex recommendation), clearly visible and easy to read.6 In Germany there is no prescribed code; footnotes, abbreviations or plain text are permitted, as long as the assignment to the dish is unambiguous and the explanation sits right next to the menu.58 The same applies to notices, meal plans and the sign at the buffet.

    2. Electronically. A digital menu via QR code, a screen or a tablet counts as written information, as long as the guest can read it before ordering without any obstacle.57 The advantage: one data set, every change instantly everywhere, and the guest can filter by their allergen instead of deciphering a key.

    3. Verbally, with conditions. The phrase "Please ask our staff" is allowed, but only as the tip of a system that stands behind it:

    Austria47Germany58
    NoticeClearly visible notice that information is given verballyNotice in a clearly visible place, clear and easy to read
    Who gives the informationPersons with documented training; the training must be recordedThe business operator or a sufficiently instructed person
    DocumentationWritten record of the allergens per dish on which the information is basedWritten or electronic documentation, easily accessible on request
    WhenOn request, before orderingOn request, without delay, before the purchase is concluded

    The conditions for verbal allergen information

    The documentation is the core. Whoever has it can also print it or put it up as a QR code; whoever does not have it is not informing verbally either, but guessing. For daily specials and changing menus, the verbal form is expressly permitted, also in combination: the standard menu in writing, the daily special verbally, both backed by documentation.9

    What "traces" mean

    The LMIV only covers allergens used as an ingredient. A note such as "may contain traces of nuts" is voluntary and does not replace the labelling.89 A menu that states across the board that all dishes may contain all 14 allergens is not allergen information, but the opposite of it.

    What inspectors check

    In Austria, inspections are carried out by the food inspectorates of the federal provinces; in Germany, by the food control authorities of the districts and cities. In both countries the inspection follows the same pattern: is there a menu with a key, or a notice that information is given verbally? Is the documentation per dish available, and immediately, not after a call to the boss? Can the person at the counter say what is in the soup? In Austria, proof of training is also required.710

    If something is missing, the first step is usually an order to remedy the shortcomings within a deadline.10 If it does not stop there, it gets expensive:

    • Austria: A breach of the Austrian Allergen Information Regulation is an administrative offence under § 90(3)(2) LMSVG, with a fine of up to 50,000 euros, or up to 100,000 euros for repeat offences.11
    • Germany: A breach of § 4 LMIDV is a regulatory offence under § 6 LMIDV in conjunction with § 60 LFGB, with a fine of up to 50,000 euros.512

    These penalty ranges are upper limits; actual fines are far below them. The real risk is a different one: a guest with anaphylaxis who was given the wrong information. Why these guests never set foot in a restaurant again after a single mistake is explained in Why allergic guests don't come back.

    The five mistakes inspectors find most often

    The official testing laboratories in Baden-Württemberg examined 577 dishes from contract catering, and 229 of them were incorrectly or incompletely labelled.2 The patterns of error from this survey and from the advisory work of the chambers of commerce keep repeating:

    1. Subgroups are missing. "Contains gluten" or "nuts" is not enough; the type of cereal and the type of nut must be named. This was the most common mistake in Baden-Württemberg.2
    2. Allergens are not assigned to the dish. A collective list at the end of the menu, without assignment per dish, is not labelling.2
    3. The blanket clause. "All dishes may contain traces of all allergens" does not meet the duty of care and does not replace any particular.9
    4. Daily menu, buffet and drinks are missing. The standard menu is labelled, but the weekly menu on the board, the breakfast buffet and the wines by the glass are not.
    5. Changes are not carried over. The supplier switches the vegetable stock, the new one contains celery, and the menu still says nothing about it. The labelling was correct on day one and has not been since.

    In one afternoon: allergen labelling step by step

    For a business with a menu of 30 to 60 dishes, the first round of labelling is an afternoon's work, if you go about it in the right order:

    1. List everything the guest can be served. Menu, daily menu, side dishes, sauces, breakfast, cake display, drinks by the glass.
    2. Break each dish down into its ingredients. Record sub-recipes such as stock, dressing, breadcrumb coating and seasoning mix only once; they go into many dishes.
    3. Take the allergens for each ingredient from the supplier's label or product specification. For cereals and nuts, note the subgroup. Where there is no label, ask the supplier; do not guess.
    4. Combine per dish and sign off. The head of the kitchen checks every line; responsibility stays with the business, not with the spreadsheet or the software.
    5. Choose the output. Menu with code and key, notice board, digital menu via QR code, or a notice plus documentation for verbal information.
    6. Train the team and document the training. Half an hour: the 14 allergens, where the list is kept, what to say when you don't know something. In Austria, documenting the training is mandatory; in Germany, it is the proof that the person is sufficiently instructed.4513
    7. Set up maintenance. Who enters a recipe change, who checks a new item from the supplier? Without that answer, even the best list goes out of date.

    To begin with, a spreadsheet is enough for the documentation. The Austrian Economic Chamber (WKO) offers a free recipe platform for it,14 and anyone who wants a digital menu anyway can have the ingredients and allergens read straight from the existing menu: HealthBlokk reads a photo or PDF of the menu, suggests the allergens per ingredient for every dish, has the kitchen confirm every entry and publishes the menu with allergens via QR code. The documentation per dish comes along as a by-product. How this differs from templates and click lists is explained in Analysing a menu under the LMIV.

    Upload your menu, see the allergens per ingredient. No account, no credit card, in about a minute. Try your menu now

    Frequently asked questions

    Do I have to label "traces" or cross-contamination?

    No. The LMIV only covers allergens that are used as an ingredient. A note about possible traces is voluntary and must not replace the labelling of the allergens actually present.89

    Does the obligation also apply to the daily menu and the buffet?

    Yes, to everything served to the guest unpackaged. Daily specials may be declared verbally if there is a notice, a trained person and documentation; combining a written standard menu with verbal information on the daily special is expressly permitted. At the buffet, a sign next to the dish or a notice provides the information.9

    Is a "Please ask our staff" sign enough?

    Only together with written documentation per dish and a person who can provide the information. In Austria this person must have documented training, in Germany they must be sufficiently instructed, and the documentation must be available immediately on request.4513

    Do I have to label drinks?

    Yes. Drinks are food, and wine by the glass almost always contains sulphites, beer contains a cereal with gluten. Both belong on the drinks menu or in the documentation.13

    Can I use the Austrian letter code in Germany?

    Yes. The LMIDV does not prescribe a particular code; any unambiguous labelling with an explanation right next to the menu is permitted. Plain text is the safest form in both countries, because the guest needs no key.58

    What happens if something is missing at an inspection?

    Usually first an order to remedy the shortcomings within a deadline. Anyone who does not comply, or provides no information at all, risks an administrative fine of up to 50,000 euros in Austria, and a regulatory fine of up to 50,000 euros in Germany.101112

    Sources

    1. Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 (LMIV), Art. 9, Art. 44, Art. 55 and Annex II, EUR-Lex ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9

    2. Untersuchungsämter Baden-Württemberg (CVUA Freiburg): allergen labelling in contract catering ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

    3. Regulation (EC) No 178/2002, Art. 2: definition of "food", EUR-Lex ↩ ↩2

    4. Allergeninformationsverordnung, BGBl. II No 175/2014, consolidated version, RIS ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

    5. Lebensmittelinformations-Durchführungsverordnung (LMIDV), § 4 and § 6, Gesetze im Internet ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9

    6. Österreichisches Lebensmittelbuch: guideline on allergen information for non-prepacked food ↩ ↩2 ↩3

    7. WKO: allergen labelling for loose food in restaurants ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

    8. Bavarian LGL: FAQ on the Food Information Regulation (LMIV) and the LMIDV ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

    9. WKO: the EU Food Information Regulation in the restaurant trade ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

    10. Unternehmensserviceportal (Austrian business service portal): allergen labelling in restaurants ↩ ↩2 ↩3

    11. § 90 LMSVG, penal provisions, JUSLINE ↩ ↩2

    12. § 60 LFGB, administrative fines, Gesetze im Internet ↩ ↩2

    13. Federal Ministry, verbrauchergesundheit.gv.at: FAQ on the Allergen Information Regulation for unpackaged food ↩ ↩2

    14. GASTRO.at: WKÖ allergen labelling, free online recipe platform ↩

    Upload your menu, see the allergens.

    No account, no credit card. In about a minute every dish is in front of you with its allergens.

    Try your menu

    More articles