Comparison · · updated · 10 min read
Analysing a menu under the EU FIC Regulation: why HealthBlokk is the best route from the paper menu to verified allergen labelling
By Shideh Heravi, Founder
If you want to analyse a menu under the EU Food Information to Consumers Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, known in German as LMIV), you will find three kinds of tool: templates you fill in yourself, digital menus with a tick-box allergen list, and recipe systems for large kitchens. HealthBlokk is none of these. It reads your existing menu, suggests the allergens per ingredient for every dish, and lets the kitchen confirm every entry before a guest sees it. This post explains why we think this is the best route, with figures and sources, and where the other tools have their strengths.
- 40 % of the dishes inspected from contract catering in Baden-Württemberg were labelled incorrectly or incompletely, 229 of 577 samples1
- 14 allergens under Annex II of the LMIV that must be documented for every dish2
- €0 is what HealthBlokk charges for the step from the paper menu to an analysed menu with allergen suggestions, no account needed3
What "analysing a menu under the LMIV" actually means
For non-prepacked food, meaning everything served in restaurants, cafés and canteens, Article 44 of the LMIV requires information on the 14 allergens listed in Annex II.2 How that information reaches the guest is regulated nationally in Austria and Germany: in Austria by the Austrian Allergen Information Regulation (Allergeninformationsverordnung) with the familiar letter codes A to R, in Germany by the German Food Information Implementing Regulation (LMIDV).45 Both allow the information to be given verbally, but only if there is written documentation for each dish that can be shown at an inspection.45 The basics, from the 14 allergens to the inspection, are covered in Allergen labelling in restaurants.
Analysing a menu is therefore not "writing letters after the dish". It has three steps, and most tools only cover the last one:
- Break down. Split every dish into its ingredients, because allergens sit in ingredients, not in dishes. The breadcrumb coating is wheat and egg, the stock may contain celery, the dressing mustard.
- Assign. Determine the Annex II allergens for each ingredient, including the sub-types for cereals and tree nuts. This is exactly where the most common error lay in the Baden-Württemberg inspection: tree nuts and cereals containing gluten were not specified, and there was no indication of which allergen was in which dish.1
- Check and approve. The kitchen confirms or corrects every entry, and that confirmation is recorded. The responsibility stays with the food business operator; a disclaimer on the menu is not permitted.46
A tool that only offers step three hands the real work, breaking down and assigning, back to the business. That is why labelling is so often wrong in practice: not out of carelessness, but because nobody goes through 60 dishes ingredient by ingredient when the tool only offers a list to tick.
The alternatives, and what they do
We looked at the tools that businesses in Austria and Germany use today to manage their allergens. The information comes from the providers themselves, as of September 2026.
| Allergens get into the system by | Reads the existing menu | Ingredient by ingredient | Kitchen confirmation recorded | Guest menu with allergen filter | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Excel or WKO template7 | Typing them in by hand | No | Only if you set it up that way yourself | No | No | Free |
| resmio, digital menu8 | Choosing from a list per dish | No | No | No | Display yes, filter not documented | Menu free, ordering feature paid |
| Speiso9 | AI reads a photo or PDF, suggests "possible allergens" per dish | Yes | No, per dish | No | Display yes | €17 per month |
| FoodNotify10 | Recipes built from ingredients and supplier data, labelling generated from the recipe | No, recipes are created | Yes | Recipe data, approval not documented | Yes | On request |
| HealthBlokk3 | AI reads a photo or PDF, breaks every dish into ingredients and suggests the allergens per ingredient | Yes | Yes | Yes, estimated or confirmed by the kitchen, with the person | Yes, filter stays on the guest's device | First analysis included with the account, then by subscription |
Allergen labelling tools compared, information from the providers
Three things stand out.
The tick-box list is the norm. resmio and most digital menus let the business pick allergens from a list for each dish.8 That is step three without steps one and two. How the owner knows the sauce contains celery is the owner's problem. It is also the approach of the free templates, just with a nicer interface.
AI reading alone is not enough. Like us, Speiso reads the paper menu from a photo and suggests allergens, which makes it HealthBlokk's closest relative, and at 17 euros a month it is cheap.9 But the suggestions come per dish, not per ingredient, and the provider itself states that they are not a legal check and that the business has to verify them.9 That is true, it applies to any software, and it is exactly the point: you can only check what lies in front of you broken down into ingredients. "Schnitzel: A, C, G" cannot be checked. "Coating: wheat flour, egg, breadcrumbs; clarified butter: milk" can.
Recipe systems start at the wrong end. FoodNotify and the large-kitchen systems generate labelling cleanly from the recipe, with supplier data and inheritance across sub-recipes.10 For a hospital kitchen with a thousand recipes, that is the right approach. For a restaurant with one menu, it means: first create every recipe, then you get your labelling. Getting started is the very work most businesses have been putting off for years.
Where HealthBlokk does better
1. We start with the menu you already have. Upload a photo or PDF, and the AI reads the dishes, prices and ingredients. No retyping, no creating recipes as a precondition. It is the same starting point as Speiso, and the reason both tools deliver a result in minutes, where resmio or FoodNotify require hours to days of preparation.39
2. We analyse per ingredient, not per dish. Every dish is broken down into its ingredients, and every ingredient carries its Annex II allergens, with sub-types. That is the difference between an estimate you have to take on trust and an analysis you can check. And it is the structure the inspection authority found missing in the 2015 inspection: which allergen in which dish, and which tree nut, which cereal.1
3. We record who confirmed what. Every entry is marked as estimated or as confirmed by the kitchen. Nothing unchecked is published. In the Pro plan, every ingredient shows who confirmed its allergens.3 That is the written documentation per dish that Austria and Germany require even when information is given verbally,45 and none of the other tools documents it as an approval step.
4. When the recipe changes, the menu changes. Swap one ingredient, and the allergens and nutritional values on the digital menu, the printed menu and the weekly menu follow, from the same record.3 With a tick-box list, nothing changes until someone remembers to change it.
5. The guest filters, and we store nothing. The digital menu opened by QR code shows the allergens per dish, the guest hides what they need to avoid, and that selection stays on their device.3 No health data on our side, nothing your business has to answer for under data protection law.
6. The first analysis is included. With an account we read your menu once, no credit card, and you see the dishes and allergens. More analyses, recipes and the menu your guests see come with a subscription.3
Where we do not
A comparison that lists only advantages is advertising. So here are the limits.
- Large kitchens. Supplier interfaces, multi-level recipes across a hundred sites, batch tracking: FoodNotify or the kitchen systems are built for that, HealthBlokk is not. If you are responsible for 2.5 million meals a day, you need the other tool.
- Ordering and payment. resmio and other systems connect the menu with reservations, ordering and the till. That is a different product. With us, labelling is at the centre, not ordering.
- The lowest price. At 17 euros a month, Speiso is cheaper than our guest menu, and a WKO template is free.79 If all you want is a menu with letters, you will find it there.
- The AI is an estimate. Ours too. What the AI reads from a photo is a suggestion that the kitchen confirms. We are better at making that suggestion checkable, not at making the check unnecessary. The responsibility stays with the business, as with any software.6
Why we still say: the best route
Not because our AI is cleverer than anyone else's. But because HealthBlokk is the only tool in this comparison that covers all three steps of an LMIV analysis, breaking down, assigning and approving, and starts from the paper menu every business already has. The others cover one or two steps and leave the rest to the owner.
Upload your menu, see the allergens per ingredient. No account, no credit card, in about a minute. Analyse your menu now
Frequently asked questions
Is an AI analysis of a menu legally sound?
No software is legally sound on its own, because under the LMIV the responsibility stays with the food business operator and a disclaimer on the menu is not permitted.6 What makes labelling legally sound is the kitchen checking and approving it. HealthBlokk makes that check possible, because the allergens are listed per ingredient, and records who confirmed them.
How is HealthBlokk different from a digital menu with an allergen list?
A tick-box allergen list shows what the owner entered. HealthBlokk breaks every dish into ingredients, suggests the allergens per ingredient and lets the kitchen confirm every entry. The difference is the analysis before the display.
Do I need HealthBlokk if I already have recipes in a kitchen system?
Probably not. If you maintain your recipes with supplier data in FoodNotify or a large-kitchen system, you already get the allergens from the recipe. HealthBlokk is for businesses still working from a paper menu or Excel that have not taken the first step yet.
What does the analysis cost?
The first analysis is included with the account, no credit card. On the home page we also read a menu without an account. More analyses and the digital menu that guests open by QR code come with a subscription from €49 a month.3
How often is allergen labelling wrong in practice?
In a 2015 inspection by the official food testing laboratories of Baden-Württemberg, 229 of 577 samples from contract catering were labelled incorrectly or incompletely, which is 40 percent. The most common error: tree nuts and cereals containing gluten not specified, and no indication of which allergen was in which dish.1
Sources
-
Untersuchungsämter Baden-Württemberg (CVUA Freiburg): Allergenkennzeichnung in der Gemeinschaftsverpflegung, allergen labelling in contract catering, inspections 2015 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 (LMIV), Art. 44 and Annex II, EUR-Lex ↩ ↩2
-
WKO: allergen labelling for loose food in hospitality (Allergenkennzeichnung bei offen angebotenen Lebensmitteln in der Gastronomie) ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Bavarian LGL: FAQ on the Food Information Regulation (LMIV) and the LMIDV ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Hygiene-Netzwerk: allergen labelling, disclaimers not permitted ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
WKO: downloads on food labelling, templates for hospitality ↩ ↩2
-
Speiso: AI menu generator, pricing and note on allergen detection ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
METRO: FoodNotify, recipe management and automatic LMIV labelling ↩ ↩2